The Chocolate Factory, located at the intersection of Washington and Columbia, is a great place to go for sandwiches and ice cream, with a central location in the heart of the historic downtown. Next door is Amy's Candy Kitchen, where you can pick from a huge variety handmade chocolates, fudge and other sweets.
Tomaso's pizzeria sells locally famous pies and serves craft Wisconsin brews in a classic "small town midcentury" restaurant, located near the Cedar Creek Settlement. Also serving pizza by the slice is Sal's, which is found just south of the City Hall campus on Washington Avenue.
Just next door to Tomaso's is the August Weber Haus, which prepares fondue to accompany its wine wine, and also features dinner in a romantic environment.
At the Cedar Creek Settlement, at the corner of Bridge Street & Washington Avenue, there are two notable eateries. The Cream & Crepe Cafe serves crepes, soups, sandwiches and other tasty meals in a pioneer-styled section of the settlement next to Cedar Creek. The Anvil is a newer restaurant opened in the former blacksmith's shop, and it serves variety of meals and Wisconsin-brewed beer.
Cedarburg also offers a thriving cafe culture. The Java House, just north of City Hall, was the first to open in 1992. The Cedarburg Coffee roaster has earned a reputation in the Midwest for excellent coffee, and beans are roasted on the premises of the Washington Avenue coffee house.
There are several classic drive-ins, including Wayne's Drive-In at five-corners, featuring roller-skating servers, Out-and-Out south of downtown, creating dozens of healthy sandwiches and wraps, and Hefner's, which is just east of downtown on Columbia Avenue and servers burgers and home-made custard.
Up the main drag in the "new" part of town is a steakhouse named the Farmstead which is always popular.
